top of page

Research That Helps Shape Children’s Dental Care: Dr Greig Taylor

Writer: KPAD
KPAD
6 days ago
6 min read
The academic work of specialist childrens dentist in newcastle

When a child has a complex dental problem, the right treatment is not always as simple as repairing the tooth in front of us.


Sometimes the bigger questions are: Will this tooth last? Is restoring it genuinely in the child's best interests? Would removing it at the right stage produce a better long-term result? And, importantly, what does the child themselves think?


These are exactly the kinds of questions that have shaped the academic career of Dr Greig Taylor, Specialist Children’s Dentist at Newcastle Advanced Dentistry.


Alongside treating children and adolescents at our Kingston Park clinic, Greig works as a clinical academic at Newcastle University and Newcastle Dental Hospital. He completed specialist training in paediatric dentistry in Newcastle and subsequently undertook a PhD funded by a National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Doctoral Research Fellowship. His research focuses particularly on complex first permanent molars, Molar-Incisor Hypomineralisation (MIH), dental trauma and how treatment decisions are made for children.


The six-year molar: an important tooth that can cause difficult decisions


One of the main themes running through Greig's research is the first permanent molar.

These are the large adult back teeth that usually begin to appear at around six years of age. Because they erupt so early, parents sometimes understandably mistake them for baby teeth.


Unfortunately, first permanent molars are also among the permanent teeth most frequently affected by problems during childhood. They can develop significant decay or may have formed with weaker enamel, leaving them painful, difficult to restore and sometimes unlikely to survive throughout adulthood.


When this happens, dentists can face a surprisingly complicated choice.


Do we repeatedly restore the tooth and try to keep it?


Or would it be better to remove it at a carefully planned stage, potentially allowing the developing teeth behind it to move forwards and reduce the long-term consequences of losing the molar?


There isn't always one obvious answer.


The DECIDE study: filling or extraction?


This uncertainty became the focus of Greig's PhD — the DECIDE study, which stands for Dental ExtraCtions versus fillings for adult teeth In children: a cost benefit/effectiveness analysis.


His research examined the competing approaches to managing compromised first permanent molars and explored not simply which treatment might work clinically, but the much broader consequences of those decisions over time.


That distinction is important.


A filling may preserve a tooth today, but a severely compromised tooth may need repeated treatment throughout childhood and adulthood. Conversely, removing a permanent tooth is irreversible and needs careful timing and planning, particularly because of its potential effect on the developing bite.


Greig's earlier research had already demonstrated considerable variation in how UK general dentists and specialists approached these teeth — highlighting just how difficult these decisions can be when the evidence is incomplete.


His subsequent work has therefore looked beyond the immediate procedure and considered long-term health outcomes, future treatment, costs and what patients and families actually value.


What matters to children when making dental decisions?


Perhaps one of the most interesting parts of Greig's research is that it has not only asked dentists what they think.


It has asked young people themselves.


In research published in the International Journal of Paediatric Dentistry, Greig and colleagues interviewed young people and adults about decisions involving compromised first permanent molars.


The young people said that professional advice was important to them, but they also wanted their own autonomy respected. The study found that, in reality, children's views were often not being heard as much as they wanted them to be.


That has an obvious relevance to children's dentistry.


A nine, ten or twelve-year-old may not be expected to make a complex healthcare decision entirely independently. But that does not mean the decision should simply happen to them.

Good children's dentistry involves explaining the problem in a way a young person can understand, listening to what matters to them and involving both the child and their parents appropriately in the decision.


Greig is continuing to investigate this area. A further Newcastle University study is specifically exploring the views of children aged 6–12 when making decisions about compromised first permanent molars — an age group particularly relevant because these decisions often need to be made before adolescence.


Looking at what families and society value


Greig's research has also taken an unusual approach by examining how the wider public values different treatment pathways.


A study published in the Journal of Dental Research involved 430 participants and explored preferences for different ways of managing compromised first permanent molars.


Participants valued avoiding future dental treatment and preferred to be involved, at least partly, in treatment decisions rather than having the dentist make the decision alone. The study also examined preferences surrounding restoration, extraction and what happened to the resulting space.


This is an area where Greig's additional training in health economics becomes particularly relevant.


Healthcare decisions cannot be assessed purely by asking whether a procedure technically succeeds. Good research also considers the burden of repeated appointments, future treatment needs, patient preferences and how healthcare resources can be used effectively.


Helping develop international guidance for MIH


Another major area of Greig's academic work is Molar-Incisor Hypomineralisation, usually shortened to MIH.


MIH is a developmental problem affecting the enamel, most commonly involving the first permanent molars and sometimes the permanent front teeth. The affected enamel can be discoloured, sensitive and considerably weaker than normal enamel.


In severe cases, the tooth can begin to break down shortly after it erupts.


Greig was one of the authors of the European Academy of Paediatric Dentistry's updated international best-practice guidance for MIH.


The guideline brought together expert assessment of the available research into both the possible causes of MIH and the different treatments available. Depending on severity, treatment can range from preventive care and restorations through to crowns or carefully planned extraction in severely affected teeth.


Greig has also helped lead collaborative research aimed at improving our understanding of MIH and ensuring the experiences of children and young people are considered when deciding how the condition should be managed.


Helping shape national guidance for extracting first permanent molars


Greig's work on compromised molars has also contributed directly to national clinical guidance.


He was a co-author of the Royal College of Surgeons of England guideline for the extraction of first permanent molars in children.


The guideline helps dentists and specialists assess situations where a first permanent molar has a poor or uncertain prognosis and an extraction is being considered.

Crucially, Greig has also written about the importance of shared decision-making in this situation: children and young people should not simply be passive recipients of treatment decisions but should, wherever possible, be included in them.


Research into dental injuries in children


Greig's research extends beyond developmental dental problems.


Dental trauma — for example, a permanent front tooth being fractured, displaced or knocked out during sport or an accident — can require immediate treatment followed by monitoring and care for many years.


In a UK study examining how specialists manage traumatic dental injuries in children aged 7–16, Greig and colleagues identified significant geographical differences in access to specialist care.


The research highlighted three recurring problems: inconsistent access to appropriate services, the need for clearer dental-trauma pathways and the need for additional training and support for general dentists managing these injuries.


The aim is straightforward: when a child suffers a significant dental injury, they should be able to reach the right clinician at the right time, wherever they happen to live.


Bringing research into everyday children's dentistry


It is easy to think of academic research as something separate from everyday clinical dentistry.


In reality, the questions Greig investigates are exactly the questions that arise when treating children.


Can this tooth be predictably restored?

What will happen to it over the next ten or twenty years?

Could removing it now avoid repeated treatment later?

How will today's decision affect the developing adult teeth?

And perhaps most importantly:

What matters to this particular child and their family?


That combination of specialist clinical training and academic research means treatment can be considered not simply in terms of today's filling or today's X-ray, but in terms of the child's long-term oral health.


Specialist Children's Dentist in Newcastle


Dr Greig Taylor provides specialist children's dental care at Newcastle Advanced Dentistry's Kingston Park clinic, alongside his academic and hospital work in Newcastle.


He accepts referrals for children and adolescents requiring more complex dental care, including management of dental decay, developmental enamel defects such as MIH, dental trauma, behavioural or anxiety-related difficulties and other conditions requiring specialist input. Inhalation sedation can also be provided where appropriate.


For parents, the term Specialist Children's Dentist is perhaps considerably more useful than the formal title of specialist in paediatric dentistry.


It means a dentist who has undertaken extensive additional training specifically in diagnosing, treating and managing dental problems in babies, children and young people — including the cases that can be particularly challenging to manage in general dental practice.


At Newcastle Advanced Dentistry, Greig combines that specialist clinical experience with research aimed at improving the evidence on which children's dental treatment decisions are based.


Because when we make decisions about a child's permanent teeth, we are not simply treating them for today.


We are planning for the adult smile they will live with for decades to come.

Comments


bottom of page